Seeking destinations with character...

Breadbakers Challenge

Some experiences take you close to home, but can still stretch your imagination about different destinations around the world. I recently noticed a Twitter post from Nicole with “Pinch My Salt” who indicated an interest in baking a loaf of bread a week from the book “The Bread Bakers Apprentice” by Peter Reinhart. This intrigued me and I tweeted back that I would like to do that, too. Soon, there were at least 20 people interested and the whole thing turned from a whim into The BBA Challenge. The group now has 200 members from around the world, including New Zealand, India, Malaysia, Sweden, France, Italy, Israel, and Slovakia, as well as throughout North America. We will bake our bread every week and post our results.

baked loaf Anadama bread

baked loaf Anadama bread

Reinhart’s book is intended to teach, and the first third of the book is devoted to method. Therefore the first recipe to bake doesn’t show up until page 108, with Anadama Bread. This bread began with a starter developed the day before baking make with cornmeal and water and left to sit on the counter. The group had detailed discussions about which cornmeal to use and how to obtain if you live in parts of the world where cornmeal isn’t readily available.

The next day I combined my ingredients, including molasses, to make a dough. Some of our bakers had already reported difficulties with the bread rising properly, so I allowed plenty of time. However, I got lucky. Both the first rise and the second rise worked perfectly.

first rise

first rise

I placed the bread pans in the oven, looking forward to warm bread out of the oven, particularly after hearing stories from others about how good it tasted.
I have to admit that my family has been spoiled in the breadbaking world. I have fiddled around with everything from holiday yeast breads to bagels. When we do purchase bread, it rarely comes in a pre-printed plastic bag. We really love good bread. Therefore, I was surprised when this bread didn’t have the flavor I was anticipating. I thought the molasses would give it a strong flavor, but I didn’t taste it. And I thought the texture was too elastic. But I didn’t say anything, because I wanted to get the reaction from the rest of the family.
My husband shrugged. He liked the other breads I had been baking lately better. The kids thought it was okay, but nothing special.
Now, maybe there was something I did wrong, or perhaps I forgot a step or ingredient. I looked back through the recipe, and all seemed right. And the bread looked beautiful. Much better, I thought, than some of the people who raved about the taste and texture. Maybe it is the dry Arizona air. Whatever it is, it wasn’t a winner, and for now, it doesn’t make my everyday bread list.
sliced bread

sliced bread

Comments (2) -> “Breadbakers Challenge”

  1. Susie
    12 May 2009 09:56
    1

    Your loaves are beautiful. I thought the Anadama was tasty but didn’t care for the crunch. :) I learned some things along the way so that is what counts and I’m having fun.
    I’m going to follow your blog and look it over as I may need your help in the future recipes. :)
    Susie in northern NY

  2. KeHoeff
    28 May 2009 20:22
    2

    hey this is a very interesting article!

Reply